Triple Witching: A GOP Guide to Navigating the Market's Quarterly Broomstick Ride

Ah, dear Republican investors, gather 'round the digital campfire as we toast to another Triple Witching Day – that most delightfully chaotic quarterly ritual where stock options, index futures, and index options all expire in a whirlwind of contracts worth trillions.

It's September 19, 2025, and with the GOP firmly at the helm of Washington, one might expect the markets to behave like a well-oiled victory parade: orderly, upward-bound, and defiantly American. Yet, as any seasoned trader knows (and as the witches themselves might cackle), expiration Fridays have a penchant for pinballing prices – especially in that final "witching hour" from 3 to 4 p.m. ET.

Fear not – today, we'll politely dissect what a "good Republican" ought to envision for the markets, blending optimism with a dash of satirical caution. After all, in this era of tax cuts and tariff triumphs, even volatility deserves a red, white, and blue spin.


The Witching Hour Primer: More Smoke Than Fire (We Hope)

For the uninitiated – or those who've been too busy cheering House Republicans' latest TCJA extension push – Triple Witching occurs four times a year on the third Friday of March, June, September, and December.

Today marks the grand convergence of over $5 trillion in expiring derivatives, per market whispers on X, as traders scramble to close, roll, or exercise positions. It's like a fiscal family reunion: everyone shows up, tempers flare, and someone always leaves with fewer chairs than they arrived with.

Historically, these days deliver a 20–30% spike in trading volume and a side of volatility, with the S&P 500 averaging a modest -0.53% dip during full witching weeks since 2017. But let's be clear: this isn't some liberal plot to unsettle the markets; it's just Wall Street's way of reminding us that even in a pro-growth paradise, gravity occasionally tugs at the stars and stripes.

In our current GOP golden age – post-April's tariff-induced "Liberation Day" hiccup, which mercifully resolved into a May rally that flipped the S&P positive for the year – the backdrop is bullish.

The Fed's fresh 25-basis-point cut on Wednesday (with two more eyed for 2025) has the Dow kissing 46,000 and the S&P lounging at 6,650 after a +0.27% nudge today. Small caps are flexing their patriotic muscles, up 4.58% in August alone, outpacing their big-brother large caps.

So, what should you, the discerning conservative steward of capital, see unfolding? A market that dances to the tune of deregulation dreams, not Democratic doomsaying.


What Good Republicans Ought to Witness: A Recipe for Red-State Resilience

Picture this, fellow patriots: As the clock ticks toward that fateful 4 p.m. close, the markets don't crumble like a poorly negotiated trade deal. Instead, they channel the unyielding spirit of 1776 – resilient, resourceful, and ready to rocket higher.

Here's the ideal script for today's performance, laced with just enough satire to keep the pointy-hatted skeptics at bay:

1. Modest Morning Jitters, Midday Manifest Destiny
Open with a polite 0.5% wobble – nothing a strong cup of black coffee (no socialist lattes, thank you) can't steady. By noon, expect a rebound as institutional investors, those modern-day minutemen, roll over futures into December's embrace.

X chatter already buzzes with "bulls still bulling from 6,560," eyeing a trigger above 6,633. Satirical aside: If the Dow dips below 45,992, blame it on lingering Biden-era ghosts; true believers know tariffs will terraform it back up by tea time.

2. Volume Surge Sans the Sorcery
Trading tallies should soar to 15–20 billion shares – a testament to America's entrepreneurial vigor – but without the Black Monday melodrama of yore.

Energy and industrials, your GOP darlings, lead the charge: oil steady at $75/barrel amid fossil-fuel favoritism, and builders like Lennar riding deregulation waves from yesterday's earnings beat.

Consumer discretionary? A cheeky 1% pop, as folks splurge on "America First" grills, not globalist gadgets. (Whisper it softly: even the Magnificent Seven – up 18% YTD – might feign humility, lest they outshine the heartland heroes.)

3. Witching Hour Waltz, Not Witch Hunt
That final hour? The real show. Volatility ticks up (VIX to 15, perhaps), but it's the good kind – the sort that shakes out weak hands while rewarding the resolute.

S&P closes +0.3% at 6,670, Nasdaq +0.5% on AI afterglow, and small caps (Russell 2000) steal the spotlight with +0.8%, echoing the small-business soul of Reaganomics.

Polite satire here: If a rogue algo (coded by a coastal elite, no doubt) sparks a fleeting 1% futures fumble, view it as market discipline – pruning the overleveraged like fiscal conservatives trim the budget.

4. Broader GOP Grins: Sectors That Salute the Flag
To sweeten the vision, here's a quick heatmap of what "good" looks like today, tailored for your red-leaning portfolio:

SectorExpected Triple Witching Tilt

Why Republicans Rejoice (With a Wink)

YTD Performance

Financials+0.5% (M&A magic)

Deregulation dances; banks lend like it's 1981.

+12%

Energy

+0.7% (Tariff tailwinds)

Fossil fuels fire up – no Green New Deal detours.

+8%

Industrials

+0.4% (Infrastructure itch)

Made-in-USA manufacturing: tariffs as the new MAGA hat.

+10%

Tech/AI

Flat to +0.2% (Hype hedge)

Innovation thrives, but don't let Silicon Valley steal it.

+18% (Mag 7)

Healthcare

+0.3% (FDA fast-track)

Pharma freedom: less red tape, more red ink for critics.

+6%


In this tableau, deficits (edging toward 7% of GDP) are mere footnotes, and tariff talks (Trump–Xi on deck) fuel the fireworks, not fizzle them.


A Satirical Spell for Serenity: Why the Witches Won't Win

Of course, one must allow for the absurd – for what is Triple Witching if not Wall Street's quarterly reminder that even eagles can get tangled in their own talons?

Imagine the headlines if the S&P sneezes: "Liberals Blame GOP Glory for Market Mischief!" Yet, in truth, today's script favors the faithful.

With Powell's dovish dot plot still echoing (two more cuts in '25? Music to Main Street's ears), and X sages foretelling "spicy" swings that spill into crypto hedges rather than catastrophe, the path is paved for progress.

So, good Republicans, raise a glass (bourbon neat, naturally) to a market that mirrors our manifest optimism: volatile yet victorious, turbulent yet triumphant.

Should the close crown a new record, tip your hat to policy prowess; if not, chalk it up to the calendar's capricious coven.

Either way, remember: in the grand ledger of liberty, today's trades are but a footnote to the enduring bull run of American exceptionalism. Boldly invest – and may your positions prosper.

But always remember: In God We Trust, witches always lose.


Highlights

Read Next

Get The Letter

More from Business


© 2025 The Letter. All rights reserved, Privacy Policy